Columbus beat Buffalo 6-3 on opening night, with Jet Greaves making 23 saves. The two teams meet again tonight in Buffalo, and the conditions are different. The Blue Jackets are on the second night of a back-to-back. Greaves is expected to start again after Cam Talbot played Thursday, and Elvis Merzlikins is listed out with a shoulder injury. Buffalo is expected to start Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen and get Jiri Kulich back after he missed five games in concussion protocol. Our pick is Buffalo Sabres moneyline.
One point comes first because it shapes everything below. Our model engine produced no output for this game. There is no model probability, no edge and no confidence rating. This pick is published without a quantified model number, and readers should weigh it accordingly.
The number
- Model probability: n/a - Market-implied probability: n/a from our engine - Edge: none published - Model confidence: none published
For reference, FanDuel lists Buffalo at -178 and Columbus at +146. Converted directly, -178 implies about 64.0% for Buffalo and +146 implies about 40.7% for Columbus. Those two figures add up to roughly 104.7%, and the extra 4.7% is the margin built into the price. Removing that margin leaves approximately 61.2% Buffalo / 38.8% Columbus.
Those are the market's numbers, not ours. Because we have no model probability to compare against them, we cannot claim an edge. The case below is qualitative. To beat the market here, Buffalo needs to win more than about 61-64% of the time in this spot, and we have no number showing that it does.
Why the pick leans Buffalo
Schedule. Columbus plays the second half of a back-to-back on the road. Talbot's Thursday start means Greaves is the expected goalie tonight. Buffalo has no comparable schedule disadvantage noted in our sources.
Goaltending availability. With Merzlikins listed out, Columbus is working through its goalie depth on consecutive nights. Luukkonen is expected to start for Buffalo, which keeps the Sabres' top option in net despite Alex Lyon being listed out.
Players in form. Zach Benson enters on a five-game point streak with 2 goals and 6 assists (8 points) in that span. Tage Thompson has 7 points over his last five games. Kulich is expected to replace Ryan McLeod, which adds a forward who had been in the lineup before his injury.
Recent form. The available snapshot is about six days old and should be treated with caution. At that point, Buffalo was 4-3-3 over its last 10 and on a two-game win streak. Columbus was 4-6-0 over its last 10 and had lost its most recent game.
Records, with a caveat. FanDuel lists Buffalo at 7-5-3 and Columbus at 7-7. An earlier preview showed different figures, so the standings are not consistent across sources. We do not lean on them.
Special teams. Neither side has an advantage here. Columbus's power play ranked 30th at 13.3%. Buffalo's ranked 28th at 13.6%. Two weak power plays may make this mostly a five-on-five game, where home ice and fresher legs matter more.
The case against
The market itself gives Columbus about 39% after removing the margin. In plain terms, this pick loses roughly two times out of five even if the price is accurate. Several specific factors could put the game in that group:
- Greaves already beat this team. He stopped 23 shots in the 6-3 opening-night win. A goalie who has already handled Buffalo's shooters can do it again, and one strong goaltending performance can outweigh a schedule disadvantage. - Buffalo's penalty kill. At 67.4%, it ranks 27th. Columbus's power play is weak, but a penalty kill at that level can still give up two goals on a few chances. Penalty trouble is the most direct path to a Columbus win. - Kent Johnson's form. He has 6 points over his last five games. Columbus has an in-form forward who can turn a close game. - Buffalo's injury list. Lyon, Justin Danforth, Konsta Helenius, Jack Rathbone and Matt Grzelcyk are all listed out. That affects depth on defense and among the forwards. Kulich is also returning from a concussion, and his first game back may not reflect his full form. - Hockey variance. One-goal games, empty-net goals and shootouts settle a large share of NHL results. Buffalo's three losses past regulation in the earlier last-10 snapshot (4-3-3) show this team can lose close games late. - No model support. Without an engine output, we cannot confirm that the -178 price undervalues Buffalo. The factors above are reasons the Sabres may win, but they are not evidence that the price is too low.
Bottom line: the qualitative case favors Buffalo. Columbus is on a back-to-back with a short-handed goalie group, and Buffalo has several forwards in form at home. However, the price is steep, the edge is unquantified, and a Columbus win at roughly 39% is a normal outcome.
21+. Predictions carry real risk of loss; set limits, never chase, and if it stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER.