Old Dominion hosts Marshall for Homecoming on Saturday, October 31, at 1 p.m. in Norfolk, Va., with the game on ESPN+. The records point in different directions. Old Dominion is 2-6 (1-4 Sun Belt) and coming off a 26-0 loss at Louisiana Tech. Marshall is 4-3 (1-2 Sun Belt) and opened as a 3.5-point favorite. Neither side has been reliable against the spread: Marshall is 2-5 ATS and Old Dominion is 1-7. The series is lopsided, with Marshall leading 10-1. There is also a staff connection: Marshall head strength coach Dwight Galt IV held the same role at ODU from 2019 to 2023.
Our pick is Under 45.5. This write-up explains the reasoning and is equally direct about what we do not know.
The number
Our model engine returned no data for this game. Here is exactly what our record shows:
- Model probability: n/a - Market-implied probability: n/a - Edge: None - Model confidence: None
This matters. We cannot quote a modeled probability or a measured edge, so this pick does not rest on a quantified advantage. The total itself is also not settled. One source lists 45.5 and another lists 44.5. We are logging the pick at 45.5. At 44.5, the Under would have one less point of cushion, and the case would be thinner.
We publish this pick on our ledger with the null fields shown as they are. Treat it as a lower-information pick than our usual output.
Why the model leans this way
Without engine output, the case rests on the researched context. There is no park factor or weather input here, and we are not citing any projected score.
1. Old Dominion's offense is close to the bottom of FBS. - The Monarchs average 250.4 yards per game (138th in FBS). - They score 15.5 points per game (133rd in FBS). - Their last outing produced zero points. - Quarterback Quinn Henicle has 656 passing yards, 4 touchdowns, 4 interceptions and a 55.1% completion rate. That profile does not suggest a sudden jump in scoring.
When one offense scores this rarely, the total depends heavily on the other team.
2. ODU games have been landing under. - The combined score of each of Old Dominion's last three games finished below the posted total. - Three games is a small sample, not proof of a pattern. - Still, it fits the season-long data: a weak offense keeps game totals down.
3. ODU's defense is still competing. - Linebacker Ja'Mez Drummer posted a career-high 15 tackles and 3.5 tackles for loss in the Louisiana Tech game. - The Monarchs allow 26.8 points per game (97th in FBS). That is below average but not a collapse.
4. Marshall's passing game is moderate. - Marshall averages 395.3 yards per game (62nd in FBS). - Carlos Del Rio-Wilson has 1,014 passing yards with 6 touchdowns and 5 interceptions. - Xayvion Turner-Bradshaw leads the receivers with 25 catches, 335 yards and 4 touchdowns. - This is a functional offense, not an explosive one. A 6-to-5 touchdown-to-interception ratio suggests drives can stall or end in turnovers.
Taken together, the Under depends on ODU staying near its season average and Marshall producing a modest share of the scoring.
The case against
There are clear ways this pick loses.
Marshall's defense is the biggest risk. - The Thundering Herd allow 430.0 yards per game. That is more than Marshall's own offense gains. - A defense giving up that much yardage can turn even a 138th-ranked offense into a scoring threat. - If ODU puts together a couple of long drives, the gap with its 15.5 PPG average closes quickly.
Old Dominion's defense can be scored on. - At 26.8 points allowed per game, ODU gives up enough that Marshall could reach the 30s. - If that happens, ODU needs only a modest output to push the total past 45.5.
Game-flow variance is real in this matchup. - Del Rio-Wilson's 5 interceptions and Henicle's 4 mean turnovers are possible on both sides. - Turnovers can produce short fields or defensive touchdowns, which raise totals in ways season averages do not capture. - The Homecoming setting and a home team looking to end a skid add some unpredictability, though we cannot measure either effect.
The line itself is uncertain. - Sources disagree on 45.5 versus 44.5. - One point matters near common final-score combinations.
We cannot estimate how often this fails. - With no model probability, we have no defensible figure for the miss rate. - The honest framing is a lean supported by ODU's season-long offensive data. It is not a quantified edge, and it could miss for any of the reasons above.
21+. Predictions carry risk; set limits and play responsibly. Help is available at 1-800-522-4700.